WINE SPECTATOR – Set the Stage for Steak

Sep 2, 2009 | News & Noteworthy

Rothmans Steak House on 54th Street is one of the best steak houses in New York. It’s both old-school (clubby atmosphere and career waiters who always remember you) and modern (sharp wine list and superfresh food). While steak and red wine go hand in hand, I love the fact that you can get a glass of this Riesling—it’s one of the house pours.
Riesling sets the palate perfectly for a big steak dinner as the acidity really gets your mouth watering for a porterhouse or filet mignon. This wine, from one of the top producers in New York’s Finger Lakes region, now has a touch of age on it, so it shows brioche and lemon zest notes along with its ripe pear and fig fruit flavors. It’s long and minerally on the finish—a textbook Riesling. I rated 88 points officially, and non-blind, it remains at this level.
A New York Riesling in a New York steak house: It fits the “buy local” trend and seems like such a good idea. I hope more places around town will serve Finger Lakes Riesling by the glass. members: Read the original blind-tasting review for  Hermann J. Wiemer • Plus, get scores and tasting notes for more recently rated Finger Lake Rieslings

Recent News

Food & Wine: Sheet Pan Recipes by Chef Nils Noren

Over the last few years, we have been fortunate to work with renowned Chef Nils Noren on an ongoing project developing recipes that pair exquisitely with our wines. Building on his illustrious culinary background, Chef Nils has blown us away with the dishes he has...

Named Wine & Spirits Top 100 Winery

We are delighted to share that we have been selected as a Wine & Spirits Magazine Top 100 Winery of the Year for 2023. This is the 13th time that we have received this honor and the news is very exciting. The W&S Fall 2023 Buying Guide, which profiles each of... Reviews our Wines

Wine writer, Stuart Pigott tasted through and reviewed a selection of our wines, including Rieslings, sparkling wines, and red wines. Highlights include our 2018 Cuvee Brut, garnering this remark, "A very elegant and creamy sparkling wine with a wonderful, seamless...